Athletes Who Worry About What Others Think

How to Develop a Comeback Mindset 

Ball Players Who Focus too Much on What Others Think

Validation is something sought after by all athletes, no matter the sport.

Every athlete tries to prove their worth whether it is:

  • To impress your coach
  • Break into the starting lineup
  • Show your teammates that you belong on the team
  • Demonstrate to your team that you can contribute to the success of the team

You want that affirmation from others around you that you are a good at your sport.

You want to be recognized for your skills. You want prove that coach was right for selecting you for the team…

You want to prove you belong on the team… You want to show everyone that you deserve that varsity jacket…

You want to be validated and gain a sense of worth as an athlete.

WOW… that’s a lot of pressure!

And why does this search for validation create pressure for many athletes?

The answer is that these types of validation are attempts to gain recognition from sources outside of you:

  • Your coaches
  • Your teammates
  • Your opponents
  • Your parents
  • Your friends
  • The press, etc.

The problem lies in that you cannot control what others think about you. Other people’s opinions could be biased. And you should not focus on what you think others think of you.

So, trying to gain approval or validation from those outside sources is a distraction and a source of pressure.

Trying to get something outside your control creates tension and anxiety.

Nonetheless, when some athletes don’t get that validation, they over-try or press when they compete, which causes performance levels to drop off significantly.

Professional athletes also fall into the “validation trap.”

Gary Sanchez, catcher for the New York Yankees, is considered by many to be the future of the franchise.

In the 2016 season, Sanchez played 53 games, hit 20 home runs, batted .299 and was the runner-up in American League Rookie of the Year voting.

Fast forward to 2018, Sanchez has only hit 16 home runs, has a batting average of .180 and has allowed 13 passed balls in 85 games.

What is the difference between his level of play in those two seasons?

The answer is his mental approach to the game.

This season, Sanchez is trying to prove that he belongs in the starting lineup, causing him to try too hard to crush the ball and press at the plate.

In 2016, Sanchez did not worry about results, things outside of his control or validation from others.

Sanchez merely focused on the things that brought him success throughout his years of playing ball.

SANCHEZ: “When I first got called up, I went oh-fer my first couple of games. I was feeling anxious because I wanted to get my first hit. And [then-manager Joe] Girardi came up to me and said, ‘Gary, take it easy. You’re going to be in the lineup every day. Just go out there and do what you would do in the minor leagues.’ That was the moment where I just felt the confidence to go out there and take some pressure off my shoulders and do what I needed to do.”

Instead of trying to impress or prove you belong, be selfish with your focus and take care of the task in front of you.

Focus on improving your game and stay focused on that process.

The only person you need to validate yourself is YOU!

Self-respect is stronger than other-respect.

How to Avoid the Validation Trap:

Play for yourself, not to make others happy or earn respect.

Think about the reasons you started your sport. What do you love about your sport?

While you may hear the opinions of others, you do not have to accept them as fact nor do you need to take on those opinions as your own.

Let go of mind reading into what others might think about your game. It doesn’t help you perform in competition.

For more strategies on overcoming high expectations and social approval, check out our audio and workbook program, “The Mental Edge For Baseball & Softball Players”:


Related Sports Psychology Articles

*Subscribe to The Sports Psychology Podcast on iTunes
*Subscribe to The Sports Psychology Podcast on Spotify


Instilling Confidence in Baseball And Softball Players

Baseball and Softball Confidence CD

Confidence, more than any other mental game attribute, is vital for your team’s success. If your players have it and know how to keep it, they maximize their success. Your team cannot reach their full potential unless each player can harness the power of stable and enduring self-confidence–so your team can perform as a confident team.

Your players might possess a ton of physical talent, have great coaching, and train harder or practice more than anyone else in your league, but if they do not have the self-confidence to match, your team can’t utilize this talent.

“Instilling Confidence in Baseball and Softball Players” program consists of one 72-minute audio CD that includes 7 days of confidence-fueling exercises. You’ll also receive a simple-to-follow 74-page coaches’ manual that guides you through the 7 team session you’ll conduct!

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.